Diagram of the Documentary Hypothesis.
* includes most of Leviticus
† includes most of Deuteronomy
‡ "Deuteronomic history": Joshua, Judges, 1 & 2 Samuel, 1& 2 Kings
The documentary hypothesis (DH) proposes that the first five books of the Old Testament (Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers and Deuteronomy, known collectively as the Torah or Pentateuch), represent a combination of documents from four originally independent sources. According to the influential version of the hypothesis formulated by Julius Wellhausen (1844 - 1918) these sources and the approximate dates of their composition were:
• the J, or
Jahwist, source; written c. 950 BC in the southern kingdom of Judah. (The name
Yahweh begins with a J in Wellhausen's native German.)
• the E, or
Elohist, source; written c. 850 BC in the northern kingdom of Israel.
• the D, or
Deuteronomist, source; written c. 621 BC in Jerusalem during a period of religious reform.
• the P, or
Priestly, source; written c. 450 BC by Aaronid priests.
The editor who combined the sources into the final Pentateuch is known as R, for Redactor, and might have been Ezra.
"Starting from the simple question of how to reconcile inconsistencies in the text, and refusing to accept forced explanations to harmonize them, scholars eventually arrived at the theory that the
Torah was composed of selections woven together from several, at times inconsistent, sources dealing with the same and related subjects. The reasoning followed in this kind of analysis is somewhat similar to that of the Talmudic sages and later rabbis who held that inconsistent clauses and terminology in a single paragraph of the Mishna must have originated with different sages, and who recognized that Moses could not have written passages of the
Torah that contain information unavailable to him, such as the last chapter of Deuteronomy, which describes his death and its aftermath."
According to Wellhausen, the four sources present a picture of Israel's religious history, which he saw as one of ever-increasing centralization and priestly power. Wellhausen's hypothesis became the dominant view on the origin of the Pentateuch for much of the 20th century. Most contemporary Bible experts accept some form of the documentary hypothesis, and scholars continue to draw on Wellhausen's terminology and insights.
Bookmarks